Thursday, February 16, 2017

Democracy, Religion, Faith, Philosophy

Image result for Faith and Democracy

Without dialogue, democracy dies. Communication is the fuel that feeds debate, debate empowers democracy. No doubt Socrates was right, Democracy can only succeed if the electorate is educated, well informed. For that, you need education, education and a free press. Intelligence without compassion is merely knowledge. Knowledge without compassion is moderation without morals. What point is having moderation managed by the immoderate? Morals matter. Without morals, humankind ceases to be human.

When we think of nations who purport to have democracy who is it we think of? The USA? The UK? Europe? You'll be surprised. The following is from the Democracy Index as compiled by UK-based Economist Intelligence Unit...

"that measures the state of democracy in 167 countries, of which 166 are sovereign states and 165 are UN member states. The index was first produced in 2006, with updates for 2008, 2010 and the following years since then. The index is based on 60 indicators grouped in five different categories measuring pluralism, civil liberties, and political culture. In addition to a numeric score and a ranking, the index categorises countries as one of four regime types: full democracies, flawed democracies, hybrid regimes and authoritarian regimes."

Democracy Index 2016
RankCountryScoreElectoral process
and pluralism
Functioning of
government
Political
participation
Political
culture
Civil
liberties
Category
1 Norway9.9310.009.6410.0010.0010.00Full democracy
2 Iceland9.5010.008.938.8910.009.71Full democracy
3 Sweden9.399.589.648.3310.009.41Full democracy
4 New Zealand9.2610.009.298.898.1310.00Full democracy
5 Denmark9.209.589.298.339.389.41Full democracy
6 Canada9.159.589.647.788.7510.00Full democracy
6 Ireland9.159.587.868.3310.0010.00Full democracy
8  Switzerland9.099.589.297.789.389.41Full democracy
9 Finland9.0310.008.937.788.759.71Full democracy
10 Australia9.019.588.937.788.7510.00Full democracy
11 Luxembourg8.8110.008.936.678.759.71Full democracy
12 Netherlands8.809.588.578.338.139.41Full democracy
13 Germany8.639.588.577.787.509.71Full democracy
14 Austria8.419.587.868.336.889.41Full democracy
15 Malta8.399.178.216.118.759.71Full democracy
16 United Kingdom8.369.587.147.228.759.12Full democracy
17 Spain8.309.587.147.228.139.41Full democracy
18 Mauritius8.289.178.215.568.759.71Full democracy
19 Uruguay8.1710.008.934.447.5010.00Full democracy
20 Japan7.998.758.216.677.508.82Flawed democracy
21 United States7.989.177.147.228.138.24Flawed democracy
21 Italy7.989.586.437.228.138.53Flawed democracy
23 Cape Verde7.949.177.866.676.889.12Flawed democracy
24 France7.929.587.147.786.258.82Flawed democracy
24 South Korea7.929.177.507.727.508.24Flawed democracy
26 Costa Rica7.889.587.146.116.889.71Flawed democracy
27 Botswana7.879.177.146.117.509.41Flawed democracy
28 Portugal7.869.586.796.676.889.41Flawed democracy
29 Israel7.859.177.508.897.506.18Flawed democracy
29 Estonia7.859.587.866.116.888.82Flawed democracy
31 Czech Republic7.829.587.146.676.888.82Flawed democracy
32 India7.819.587.507.225.639.12Flawed democracy
33 Taiwan7.799.588.216.115.639.41Flawed democracy
34 Chile7.789.588.574.446.889.41Flawed democracy
35 Belgium7.779.588.575.006.888.82Flawed democracy
36 Cyprus7.659.176.436.676.889.12Flawed democracy
37 Slovenia7.519.587.146.675.638.53Flawed democracy
38 Lithuania7.479.585.716.116.259.71Flawed democracy
39 South Africa7.417.927.868.335.007.94Flawed democracy
40 Jamaica7.399.176.795.006.889.12Flawed democracy
41 Latvia7.319.585.715.566.888.82Flawed democracy
42 Slovakia7.299.587.145.565.638.53Flawed democracy
43 Timor-Leste7.248.677.145.566.887.94Flawed democracy
44 Greece7.239.585.366.116.258.82Flawed democracy
45 Panama7.139.586.436.115.008.82Flawed democracy
46 Trinidad and Tobago7.109.587.145.565.008.24Flawed democracy
47 Bulgaria7.019.176.077.224.388.24Flawed democracy
48 Indonesia6.977.757.146.676.257.06Flawed democracy
49 Argentina6.969.175.006.116.887.65Flawed democracy
50 Philippines6.949.175.717.224.388.24Flawed democracy
51 Brazil6.909.586.795.563.758.82Flawed democracy
52 Poland6.839.175.716.674.388.24Flawed democracy
53 Suriname6.779.176.435.005.008.24Flawed democracy
54 Croatia6.759.176.075.565.007.94Flawed democracy
54 Ghana6.758.335.716.116.257.35Flawed democracy
56 Hungary6.729.176.074.446.887.06Flawed democracy
57 Dominican Republic6.678.755.715.006.257.65Flawed democracy
57 Colombia6.679.177.144.444.388.24Flawed democracy
59 Peru6.659.175.366.114.388.24Flawed democracy
60 El Salvador6.649.176.074.445.008.53Flawed democracy
61 Romania6.629.175.715.005.008.24Flawed democracy
61 Mongolia6.629.175.715.005.008.24Flawed democracy
63 Lesotho6.598.255.366.675.637.06Flawed democracy
64 Serbia6.578.755.366.675.007.06Flawed democracy
65 Malaysia6.546.927.866.116.255.59Flawed democracy
66 Sri Lanka6.487.836.795.006.885.88Flawed democracy
67 Mexico6.477.926.077.224.386.76Flawed democracy
68 Hong Kong6.423.925.715.567.509.41Flawed democracy
69 Tunisia6.406.006.077.786.255.58Flawed democracy
70 Singapore6.384.337.866.616.257.35Flawed democracy
71 Namibia6.315.675.366.675.638.24Flawed democracy
72 Paraguay6.278.335.715.004.387.94Flawed democracy
73 Guyana6.258.335.366.114.387.06Flawed democracy
74 Senegal6.217.925.364.446.257.06Flawed democracy
75 Papua New Guinea6.036.926.073.895.637.65Flawed democracy
76 Moldova6.017.924.296.114.387.35Flawed democracy
77 Zambia5.997.085.363.896.886.76Hybrid regime
78 Georgia5.938.674.296.115.005.59Hybrid regime
79 Honduras5.929.175.713.894.386.47Hybrid regime
79 Guatemala5.927.926.073.894.387.35Hybrid regime
81 Albania5.917.004.365.565.007.65Hybrid regime
82 Ecuador5.818.254.645.004.386.76Hybrid regime
83 Tanzania5.767.005.005.566.255.00Hybrid regime
84 Bangladesh5.737.425.075.004.386.76Hybrid regime
85 Montenegro5.727.085.365.004.386.76Hybrid regime
86 Ukraine5.705.833.936.675.007.06Hybrid regime
86 Mali5.707.423.934.446.256.47Hybrid regime
88 Benin5.676.505.365.005.635.88Hybrid regime
89 Fiji5.644.585.716.675.635.59Hybrid regime
90 Bolivia5.637.005.365.003.757.06Hybrid regime
91 Malawi5.556.584.294.446.256.18Hybrid regime
92 Kenya5.334.335.006.675.635.00Hybrid regime
93 Liberia5.317.832.575.565.005.59Hybrid regime
94 Uganda5.265.253.574.446.886.18Hybrid regime
95 Macedonia5.236.923.216.113.756.18Hybrid regime
96 Madagascar5.075.923.575.565.634.71Hybrid regime
97 Turkey5.045.836.075.005.632.65Hybrid regime
98 Kyrgyzstan4.937.422.935.563.755.00Hybrid regime
98 Bhutan4.938.335.362.784.383.82Hybrid regime
100 Thailand4.924.503.935.005.006.18Hybrid regime
101 Bosnia and Herzegovina4.876.502.935.003.756.18Hybrid regime
102 Lebanon4.864.422.147.784.385.59Hybrid regime
102   Nepal4.864.334.294.445.635.59Hybrid regime
104 Nicaragua4.814.503.293.895.636.76Hybrid regime
105 Morocco4.774.754.644.445.634.41Hybrid regime
106 Burkina Faso4.704.424.294.445.634.71Hybrid regime
107 Venezuela4.685.672.505.564.385.29Hybrid regime
108 Sierra Leone4.555.681.862.786.255.29Hybrid regime
109 Nigeria4.506.084.293.334.384.41Hybrid regime
110 Palestine4.494.332.147.784.383.82Hybrid regime
111 Pakistan4.336.005.362.782.505.00Hybrid regime
112 Cambodia4.273.175.713.335.004.12Hybrid regime
113 Myanmar4.203.173.574.446.882.94Hybrid regime
114 Iraq4.084.330.077.224.384.41Hybrid regime
115 Mozambique4.024.422.145.005.003.53Hybrid regime
115 Haiti4.025.172.212.223.756.76Hybrid regime
117 Mauritania3.963.004.295.003.134.41Authoritarian
117 Jordan3.964.004.293.894.383.24Authoritarian
117 Niger3.964.752.212.223.756.76Authoritarian
120 Armenia3.884.332.864.441.885.88Authoritarian
121 Kuwait3.853.174.293.894.383.53Authoritarian
122 Ivory Coast3.813.422.863.335.633.82Authoritarian
123 Gabon3.742.582.214.445.633.82Authoritarian
124 Comoros3.714.332.214.443.753.82Authoritarian
125 Ethiopia3.600.003.575.565.633.24Authoritarian
126 Algeria3.562.582.213.895.004.12Authoritarian
127 Belarus3.541.333.573.896.252.65Authoritarian
128 Cameroon3.462.003.213.894.383.82Authoritarian
128 Cuba3.461.754.643.894.382.65Authoritarian
130 Angola3.400.923.215.564.382.94Authoritarian
131 Vietnam3.380.003.213.896.882.94Authoritarian
132 Togo3.323.581.142.785.004.12Authoritarian
133 Egypt3.312.583.933.333.752.94Authoritarian
134 Russia3.242.672.505.002.503.53Authoritarian
135 Qatar3.180.003.932.225.634.12Authoritarian
136 China3.140.004.643.336.251.47Authoritarian
137 Guinea3.143.500.434.444.382.94Authoritarian
138 Rwanda3.070.835.002.224.382.94Authoritarian
139 Kazakhstan3.060.502.144.444.383.82Authoritarian
140 Zimbabwe3.050.502.003.895.633.24Authoritarian
141 Oman3.040.003.932.784.384.12Authoritarian
142 Swaziland3.030.922.862.225.633.53Authoritarian
143 Republic of the Congo2.911.672.863.333.752.94Authoritarian
143 Gambia2.911.753.212.225.002.35Authoritarian
145 Djibouti2.830.422.143.335.632.65Authoritarian
146 Bahrain2.791.253.212.784.382.35Authoritarian
147 United Arab Emirates2.750.003.572.225.002.94Authoritarian
148 Azerbaijan2.650.502.143.333.753.53Authoritarian
149 Afghanistan2.552.501.142.782.503.82Authoritarian
150 Burundi2.40-0.330.793.895.002.65Authoritarian
151 Sudan2.370.001.793.895.001.18Authoritarian
151 Eritrea2.370.002.141.676.881.18Authoritarian
151 Laos2.370.832.861.675.001.47Authoritarian
154 Iran2.340.003.213.893.131.47Authoritarian
155 Libya2.251.000.001.675.632.94Authoritarian
156 Yemen2.070.000.004.445.000.88Authoritarian
157 Guinea-Bissau1.981.670.002.783.132.35Authoritarian
158 Uzbekistan1.950.081.862.225.000.59Authoritarian
159 Democratic Republic of the Congo1.930.920.712.784.380.88Authoritarian
159 Saudi Arabia1.930.002.862.223.131.47Authoritarian
161 Tajikistan1.890.580.071.676.250.88Authoritarian
162 Turkmenistan1.830.000.792.785.000.59Authoritarian
163 Equatorial Guinea1.700.000.432.224.381.47Authoritarian
164 Central African Republic1.611.750.361.112.502.35Authoritarian
165 Chad1.500.000.001.113.752.65Authoritarian
166 Syria1.430.000.002.784.380.00Authoritarian
167 North Korea1.080.002.501.671.250.00Authoritarian
Any individual who states they support democracy has to be able to discuss their point of view without fear of abuse from another. The abuser abuses those they cannot debate for lack of a solid argument. Disapprobation of political policies based on moral grounds cannot be wantonly maltreated purely because what is being said upsets one person's point of view. The whole point of democracy is to air opinions the better to create a moral, just society. Without this balance harmonious accord fractures into a distinct division. And there is too much division in this world and too little love and compassion.

The same is true of religion as it is of politics. Exclusivism excludes. Having your own faith is all fine and dandy but not when belief belittles others of a different faith. Singularity slides into division perpetuating discord. What is surely needed is a plurality.  Exclusivism comes awfully close to fundamentalism much in the way neoliberalism comes awfully close to authoritarianism, even fascism. Extremism of any sort is not only fundamentalism but fundamentally flawed. 

I am a non-theist, that is I do not worship or follow a single, or a pantheon, of deities. That being so does not mean I need be disrespectful to those who do. For me, God is but a word that describes the unknowable, the undefinable. Tao is another for Tao means the way and early Christian's believed their worship of God was the way. If we hold true to the Golden Rule, if we hold true to being compassionate and loving toward all sentient beings then surely having a kinship of faiths is preferable?

To achieve this we must have discourse with those of other faiths. We must endeavour to listen even when sceptical and to be respectful at all times for those other faiths, those other philosophies all hold true to the same Golden Rule I live my life by.


The key to democracy, religion, faith and philosophy is communication and to communicate we must listen.  


Tuesday, February 14, 2017

The Cheese Grates It: It's Not Love

My trophy for the shit I didn't say but really wanted to

I abhor trolls who hide behind anon to say terrible things to people whose opinions they don't agree with, and most of the time I would never even consider going on anon. I'll either say what I have to say, or I'll say nothing.
That being said, I almost went on anon to cuss someone out once. 
My reason for potentially going on anon was the knowledge that the person whom I was considering lambasting had a cult following, and I didn't want to deal with the resulting personal attacks that I knew would come after. I was, however, extremely disgusted by this person's actions and was burning to tell her that she was a horrible human being.
The young woman in question, whom I will refer to as Little Annie Wilkes, had a blog dedicated to her romantic/lustful feelings for David Bowie. Little Annie spoke gushingly about how she had fallen in love with David as a young teenager. Little Annie wasn't like most of the teenagers who become enamored with photos taken 30, 40 and 50 years ago of men now old enough to be their grandfathers. She was articulate and managed to draw a fan base from the aforementioned demographic. I happened upon her blog while looking for pictures of David Bowie to add to my collection.
Initially, I ignored this girl's inappropriate gushing over a talented musician whom I felt deserved better than to be objectified. I told myself that she was a troubled kid. In fact, I thought I could be supportive of her. So I continued following her, every now and then leaving some sort of encouraging comment.
I realize now that what got under my skin was the way this young lady manipulated her followers so that the tragedy of David Bowie's death was now focused on her. In her words, she was so crushed by David's passing that she couldn't go to school or work, and her mother was terribly worried about her. She garnered great sympathy from her followers, encouraging her to keep her head up. Something smelled fishy, but I told myself to be kind. I wrote her a personal email, telling her that she evidently had strong empathic abilities and she should work to hone them. I told her that I felt she had the ability to help a lot of people. I said that David wouldn't want her to break down, that he'd want her to be strong and keep going. I related to her the story of how crushed I felt when I was 15 years old and Bon Scott died four days after my birthday in 1980.
The email I got back from Little Annie made clear to me that I wasn't wrong about the alarm bells and red flags warning me that something wasn't right. Her private persona was very different from the "poor sweet girl" persona she presented online. She was selfish and cold, and her "love" for David Bowie was not the result of being too emotional and becoming attached to someone who seemed kind and expressed himself in ways that touched her heart. 
As it turns out, Little Annie is the sort of person who mimics emotions well but doesn't have any real emotions of her own. I'm not sure why she dropped her guard with me, but arrogance is a reasonable guess. She thanked me for caring about her but said that she was going to be "just fine," she wasn't the sort of "weak" person who would try to commit suicide or such. She said that her "love" for David Bowie had "served her well" and that while she was "sad" he was gone, she was going to be "all right." 
Now that I knew that Little Annie was, in fact, a self-serving chameleon pretending to "love" David Bowie, a real person whom I had cared about and been a fan of since the 1970's, really upset me. Knowing that she was tricking vulnerable and ignorant teenagers into believing that she was some sort of "leader" for them made me angry. 
The icing on the cake came when one of Little Annie's followers wrote her a gushing tribute, saying how her "love" for David was so strong and beautiful and that he would have been "a fool" not to fall in love with her if he had met her. Little Annie published this tribute on her blog.
This really incensed me. Not only was I aware of this young woman's actual personality by this point, but I was disgusted that she continued to objectify a person who had recently died from cancer, a man who was a husband and a father, a man old enough to be her grandfather. I felt that her actions were utterly disrespectful, and I felt that it was disrespectful of her not to keep this conversation between herself and her admirer rather than broadcasting it for all the world to see so she could feed her ego when her followers gushed over how "beautiful" it was. 
Further, I was enraged at the idea that these girls thought it was okay to imply that David would leave the woman to whom he had been married for 24 years to pursue a tryst with a ridiculous child close to 45 years his junior.
It was at this point that I almost went on anon to demand that Little Annie Wilkes explain how she could possibly think it was okay to disrespect not only a man who had recently died from a devastating illness but his widow. I wanted her to know that I found her declarations of "love" for him disgusting, and that I knew she didn't love him at all, or respect him, or care about his music, but only lusted after his image in pictures from thirty and more years ago.
In the end I didn't do this because it would have made the person in question a martyr with her devotees. I would have ended up being painted as the "bitter old bitch" who was jealous of poor Little Annie's popularity. It wouldn't have helped David Bowie in any way and it would have made my life worse. So I kept my mouth shut, even though I was horrified and appalled by this young woman's disrespectful actions.
I'm not a hero for having been "kind." I wasn't kind, I was self-serving. I stopped following Little Annie and any members of her cult because I didn't ever want her blog coming across my path again. I do wish I knew the sources she used to find her pictures, though. She managed to get hold of some amazing rarities.

~The Cheese Hath Grated It~


Note:
Annie Wilkes is the main antagonist from Stephen King's novel, Misery. She is an obsessed fan who kidnaps and tortures the object of her obsession.