Monday, April 9, 2018

30 Days of De-Objectification: Insistence


Don't be the fan who insists that everyone must obey you about everything or you'll go around starting fights with everyone.

30 Days of De-Objectification:
Insistence


Thus far, I’ve focused mainly on the (so-called) “classic rock fandom” of Tumblr and their insistence on objectifying ageing and dead musicians; which, as it happens, is a really gross thing to do. In this installment, I will diversify to include other fandoms (and their problems) as well.
Today’s issue is INSISTENCE.
What do I mean by insistence?
Primarily, the insistence that a performer IS the way the fan has perceived them, regardless of what said performer may say on their own behalf. This can also extend to the insistence that a character IS a certain way or is involved in a certain relationship with another character, regardless of what the creator or performer of said character may say to refute such ideas.
Regarding characters, the beauty of fan fiction is the ability to place the character in whatever scenario the fan wishes. Let us create an example scenario.
Betty Blergsnorf really likes the show “Dolly’s House.” But she hates the way the creators wrapped up the show by having Dolly marry Edgar Quiverjewels and run off to Russia. Betty thinks it would have been much nicer if Dolly had instead gotten together with Terry Ultra and stayed in the quiet little Virginia town where most of the show took place.
It’s perfectly legitimate for Betty to say “hahaha, nope, that didn’t happen!” and to write her own account of what she feels should have happened for her beloved characters.
Betty’s version may even be more enjoyable than the canon version for other fans of Dolly’s House, who may also think that Edgar Quiverjewels is a loathsome leech who is just using Dolly for her money.
What is not fine is for Betty and her like-minded cronies to browbeat and even threaten the creative team involved with Dolly’s House. Sending messages like “U should kill urself u disgusting shitlord I hope ur children die of cancer”, or, worse, doxing your target, is never okay.
Another issue I see arise all too often, particularly regarding television series, is the insistence that the show is “queerbaiting” the audience. People don’t seem to understand the difference between “queerbaiting” and fan servicing.
Scenario time!
A certain faction of fans of the show “Poltergeist Patrol” feel that the “longing looks” between General Gordon Geist of the Ghost Army and Warrant Officer William Ward of the Wraith Squadron were deliberately written in to create sexual tension and raise fans’ hopes that Gordon Geist and Will Ward will get together in canon.
A puzzled Irving Ives, the actor who plays William Ward, denies the existence of any “longing looks.”
Most fans accept Ives at his word, and those who enjoy the GeistWard ship go back to writing fan fiction in peace.
Except for a certain rabid and irrational faction of the fandom who insist that “Poltergeist Patrol” is queerbaiting the fans and that the writers are using underhanded tactics to indicate canon GeistWard, such as having Will Ward drink coffee at Pinky Pie’s Divine Diner with its fabulous pink neon sign out front.
Everyone knows that Will Ward usually drinks tea at Tom’s Tea Room, and everyone knows that Vincent von Vermillion, the actor who plays Gordon Geist, can’t function without his coffee. Thus, Will Ward is obviously bisexual, in spite of the fact that he has hooked up with ninety percent of the female officers on the Wraith Squadron, seventy-five percent of the female officers in the Ghost Army, and no few of the women rescued by the Poltergeist Patrol and has never hooked up with a man.
The writers insist that the Tom’s Tea Room set was undergoing repairs during the shooting of the episode in question, so they relocated to the Pinky Pie’s Divine Diner set. Since it would be unlikely that Pinky Pie’s Divine Diner serves Earl Gray, Will Ward opted for coffee instead.
The GeistWard purists insist that the writers are lying.
When a frazzled Irving Ives attempts to clarify that there is no secret romance between Gordon Geist and William Ward, the angry GeistWard fanatics accuse him of being a homophobe. Although Irving initially wishes to appease fans of the show in which he stars, he eventually becomes frustrated with the behavior of the irrational GeistWard devotees and bluntly states that GeistWard will never happen. He is branded a homophobe and an asshole and sent death threats.
As bad as irrational insistence is when applied to fictional characters, it is even worse when applied to real people.
As stated before, I don’t take issue with people seeing a dynamic, saying a certain pair of people would make a cute couple, or even a degree of tinhatting, as long as it isn’t taken too far.
Thinking that there might be something more to a given person’s relationship with their co-star or the drummer in their band or what have you based on over-the-top touchy-feely behavior between the pair is one thing.
Insisting that there MUST be a romantic and sexual relationship rather than a platonic one and making hateful statements regarding the real-life significant others that the people in the pairing may be involved with is quite another.
Saying “I really think that Tommy Topper and Timmy Tweedle are more than just friends. I mean, they’re always grabbing each other’s butts and looking at each other’s crotches. It sucks that they can’t just be out in the open with their relationship because show business is still pretty homophobic overall,” is one thing.
Saying “I hate that damn Susie Sassafras for marrying Tommy Topper. She’s just standing in the way of his true love with Timmy Tweedle. That bitch needs to die,” is quite another.
Irrational insistence when applied to real people is a form of objectification because it insists that people must behave in a certain way to please the insistent fan.
It is one thing to be disappointed that a performer’s actions don’t live up to one’s beliefs about who they are. It is another to be obsessed with the idea that said performer should be a certain way.
Saying: “I went to a meet and greet for Nine Foot Screws, and I always thought that Rockin’ Ron was a really cool guy, but he was actually a lecherous drunk asshole, and it really broke my heart to learn that my hero is nothing but a zero” is understandable.
Saying: “I went to a horror convention and I wanted Irving Ives and Vincent von Vermillion to put on their Poltergeist Patrol costumes and make out for my photo op, but Irving Ives wouldn’t do it, so he’s just a homophobic shitlord who should die horribly” is a problem.
Don’t be “that fan.”

~The Cheese Hath Grated It~





Sunday, April 8, 2018

30 Days of De-Objectification: Heavy Metal Angel

Per Yngve Ohlin, AKA Dead
January 16, 1969 - April 8, 1991

30 Days of De-Objectification:
Heavy Metal Angel

The tragic tale of Per Yngve Ohlin, vocalist for the Swedish death metal band Morbid and the Norwegian black metal band Mayhem, evokes strong emotional responses. Per suffered from severe psychological disturbances. Reading about him in the chapters translated into English from Blod Eld Död, I have the feeling that he may have been autistic. He would become greatly upset if disturbed while performing a task. Despite his intelligence, evidenced in his thoughtful and provocative song lyrics and his clever though disturbing artwork, he did poorly in school.
After Per’s parents divorced, he changed schools. His previous classmates were used to his unusual behavior and were generally tolerant of him. His new schoolmates bullied him, and, on one occasion, beat him so severely that he ended up clinically dead. Following this event, he became obsessed with death and referred to himself as not being alive. The head trauma he incurred from the assault may have caused him to develop Cotard Syndrome, a rare condition in which a person believes their body is dead.
Although he has been gone from this world for twenty-seven years, Per continues to be exploited, both by those who insist on seeing him as some sort of icon for evil and those who look only at his physical appearance without seeing the very troubled human being behind the flowing blond hair and the striking, angular face.
Per was obsessed with occult imagery, but he wasn’t truly evil. He was angry at a world which had caused him grievous harm. Many of those who attacked him probably identified as “good Christians.” It’s no wonder that he wanted to be the opposite of his attackers or that he dreamed of being able to exact revenge against those who injured him.
As for the idea of Per being some sort of sex god, there is no evidence that he was ever sexually involved with anyone or that he even had any interest in sex. There have been fantasies written about him by a certain contingent of horny female fans, usually postulating him as some sort of vampire king or demon lord. I wish I could say these fictions were worthy of their subject. Most of them are poorly written and I wouldn’t feel right about quoting the explicit and ludicrous scenarios postulated therein.
Worst of all, there are still people who see fit to share the actual, post-suicide image photographed by Per’s former bandmate, Øystein "Euronymous" Aarseth. My opinions of Aarseth are not exactly favorable, but I became somewhat more sympathetic to him after viewing interviews with his former bandmates and schoolmates, Kjetil Manheim and Jorn “Necrobutcher” Stubberud.
Regardless of my personal opinions of Euronymous, photographing the corpse of your housemate, even if you weren’t particularly kindly disposed to him, is unconscionable. As the surviving members of Morbid said on the liner of their 2011 release, The Year of the Goat, “No thanks to the distributors and buyers of the post-mortem pic. Fuck you.”
Those words of wisdom sum things up perfectly.

With love and respect,
Cie



Being Positive


Saturday, April 7, 2018

30 Days of De-Objectification: Gay Men



Fandoms have a gay male problem, and it isn’t what you’d expect.
The problem isn’t that fans like people and characters who happen to be gay.
The problem is that said “fans” fetishize the idea of two men having sex.
Further, these “fans” go on to claim that their assertions are true, even in cases where the assertions have been denied, and they claim that anyone who does not follow the same line as thinking is “homophobic.”
Example time!
It’s fine to enjoy Yaoi anime. I’m a great fan of anime, although I’m not the sort who will win at anime trivia. No small portion of the anime I’ve enjoyed has been Yaoi.
I’m not saying it’s bad to find Yaoi erotic. However, when someone is screeching about how an anime was Teh Bestest because it was totes Teh Gayest, they aren’t appreciating the anime for an interesting story or compelling characters.
Similarly, it’s fine if someone sees a dynamic between two canonically straight, same-sex characters. Movies and television continue to have a problem with heteronormativity, and many times the canon straight relationships are, frankly, a bore. They often seem shoehorned in because you’ve got to have X number of fake sex scenes in a given season. Dullsville. I often do something else like check my email or try to bash through a bit of accounting until the fake sex scene is over.
However, it is not fine to claim that Splortgloppy (a ship between the same-sex characters Splort and Gloppy) WILL BE CANNON 3k69!!!!111!! and anyone who doesn’t agree that Splortgloppy should be CANNON is a RAGEING HOMOPHOBE!!!11!!! It is not fine to harass the show’s producers, writers, actors, and the other fans of the show.
It is also not cool to claim that Splortgloppy is Seekritly Cannon because Splort was wearing the Zoot Suit with the Trisexual Colors and Gloppy ate Triffle Truffles when ze usually eats Pansnoodles, while standing in front of a glowing sign which said Muzzleblum, but the Blum part of Muzzleblum was covered up, which means ZOMG, SPLORTGLOPPY IS TOTES CANNON 3K69!!11!!!11
Sexuality is not determined by what a person wears or eats or the music they listen to or the sign they’re standing beside. This is gross stereotyping. Also, not seeing the chemistry in a given ship does not make a person a homophobe. It just means they’re not into that ship. A person does not automatically become a raging homophobe because they aren’t on board with a certain ship.
Then there are the people who decide that nobody can have a close platonic relationship with a person of the same sex. If two people of the same sex are physically affectionate in any way, they are automatically totes banging.
I’m tolerant of a degree of Tinhatting. Some of the nicest people are Tinhats. The problem isn’t Tinhatting itself. The problem happens when people harass the objects of their Tinhat theories. Harry Styles and Louis Tomlinson (One Direction) have said that people harassing them about their supposed “hidden romance” harmed their real-life friendship, because they became uncomfortable being at all affectionate with one another in public. I think that’s sad. A good friend is a treasure. A person shouldn’t have to be afraid to hug on their friend without a certain fan contingent vehemently insisting that they’re totes banging said friend.
It’s worse when one member of the ship pairing is dead, particularly when they died violently. John Lennon was a real person, not just a handsome dude in a picture on an album cover. He was murdered by a deranged fan. I find shipping him with his former bandmates disrespectful and minimizing of his contributions in life and of his untimely, violent death.
I think that Angus Young has been through so much tragedy that shipping him with anyone besides his real-life wife of close to forty years is incredibly disrespectful. Angus was not in a clandestine seekrit love affair with Brian Johnson. He was not sexually involved with Bon Scott just because they had a physically affectionate relationship. He was certainly not sexually involved with his brother Malcolm, although they were completely personal-space oblivious in one another’s presence. That’s called being soul mates. Most soul mate relationships are platonic. It’s sad when people perceive any degree of physical affection as automatically meaning ZOMG, TOTES BANGING!
I have seen all the above (badly written) ships, and my reaction ranges from massive eyeroll to “what the actual fuck is wrong with you?” Usually I ignore the bullshit. There have been a couple of cases where I reported what I’d read because I felt it was slanderous. I really don’t understand how some people can be so utterly disgusting and without regard for others.
I’m not opposed to Real People Fics when they are done respectfully and when the people being depicted don’t seem to mind speculations about their relationship. Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles don’t seem bothered by the speculations. Other people may not be as comfortable with such. The wishes of the real people involved need to be respected.
I find it interesting that the people who are the most insistent that their interpretation is reality are less interested in actual gay people and characters than they are in insisting that heterosexual people and characters are Seekritly Gay For Each Other. Perhaps this interpretation leaves room for an unspoken threesome between the two men and the girl or woman making the interpretation.
This is fine when such an interpretation is:
a)      Acknowledged for what it is and
b)      Kept on the down-low (sometimes between the interpreter and themselves is best)
It is not fine when the interpreter insists that their interpretation is TOTES REALITY and anyone who disagrees with her is disagreeing because they are a BIG OLE HOMOPHOBE!!!!11!!!!
A person is not a homophobe for disagreeing that Snorkles (a Real People ship between the actors Sneed Snork and Lester Longbottom) is TOTES REALITY and instead thinks that Sneed Snork and Lester Longbottom are simply platonic friends or even just performers on the same program.
TL: DR
It is fine to acknowledge that most TV series and movies are still heavily heteronormative.
It is fine to see a potential homosexual relationship between two characters who are canonically heterosexual.
It is even fine to see a potential romantic and sexual relationship between two characters who are canonically related. These characters are not real people.
It is not fine to harass a movie or television show’s producers, directors, writers, performers, and even other fans for not agreeing with your interpretation.
It’s okay to see a dynamic between two real people, but since they are real people, it is best to tread carefully and be respectful.
It is not okay to force your interpretation of a sexual relationship on real people simply because you think it would be “hot.”
Homosexuality is a real and valid sexual orientation. Gay people are not on this planet to be fodder for shipper fantasies. They are simply people who are attracted to people of the same sex.
Two men having a physically affectionate relationship does not make them gay. Some people are just physically affectionate by nature. Some people may not be physically affectionate by nature in most cases but are comfortable enough with a given person that they are physically affectionate with that person. Such displays of affection are not signs that the people involved are in a sexual relationship.
There is still a lot of work to be done to resolve the tendency to heteronormativity in mainstream movies and television. There need to be more canonically gay and bisexual characters. I won’t argue with that for a minute. However, insisting that a certain pair of characters need to be in a relationship with each other because that would be hot for representation or else everyone is a big mean homophobic meanie does not help forward this agenda, in fact it holds back progress.
Ship peacefully and respectfully.

The Cheese Hath Grated It